'Live and let live': Northern Ireland historian uncovers surprising era of tolerance of gay men

Public records and private papers reveal compassion and tacit acceptance before ‘moral panic’ took hold in the 1950s and 1960s

'Live and let live': Northern Ireland historian uncovers surprising era of tolerance of gay men

TL;DR

  • Historically, Northern Ireland had a reputation for homophobia, with figures like Ian Paisley leading anti-homosexuality crusades and law enforcement targeting gay men.
  • Research by historian Tom Hulme suggests a more tolerant period in the Victorian era and early 20th century, characterized by "benevolent toleration" and a "live and let live" ethos.
  • During this earlier period, male queerness could exist discreetly, with communities often showing compassion and turning a blind eye to sexual orientation as long as discretion was maintained.
  • A "major moral panic" emerged in the 1950s and 1960s, forcing religious and political leaders to take a stance against homosexuality.
  • Despite later opposition, including the DUP blocking same-sex marriage until 2019, gay rights activists achieved landmark victories, such as the decriminalization of homosexual sex in 1981.