So long, hereditary peers – but the Lords is still full of absurd anachronisms

Two-thirds of voters want an elected second chamber. The government needs a radical legacy: it should use its rare majority for this

So long, hereditary peers – but the Lords is still full of absurd anachronisms

TL;DR

  • Two-thirds of voters desire a democratically elected second chamber.
  • The recent removal of hereditary peers was met with resistance and threats from Tory peers in the Lords.
  • The Salisbury convention, which respects a government's manifesto, was violated by the Lords.
  • Some peers' arguments for retaining hereditary membership were based on a desire for "political chancers" and a perceived badge of honor in their "lack of legitimacy."
  • Tory peers, including Lord True, employed aggressive procedural tactics to retain some hereditary peers as life peers.
  • A small group of peers is obstructing the assisted dying bill, despite public and Commons support.
  • The Lords have influenced policy, forcing a watering down of new employment rights.
  • The article suggests reforms like quotas for parties to select peers and an age cap, but prefers party-determined selection.
  • Remaining anachronisms include unelected former hereditary peers and bishops, which are linked to the "spirit of sovereignty" that led to Brexit.
  • Donations significantly influence peerages, with substantial amounts linked to access and honors.
  • Past attempts at Lords reform have been stalled by conflicting alternatives.
  • The government is urged to use its majority for radical reform, potentially by summoning a commission to devise a senate.
  • There are concerns that Labour may be retreating from constitutional reform, which would be a victory for the departing peers.