How the Supreme Court Came to Accept a Practice It Called Unjust

The Court went from condemning partisan gerrymandering to effectively encouraging it.

How the Supreme Court Came to Accept a Practice It Called Unjust

TL;DR

  • The Supreme Court, in *Rucho v. Common Cause*, acknowledged partisan gerrymandering as pernicious and unjust but concluded federal courts had no role in policing it.
  • The recent decision in *Louisiana v. Callais* encourages states to use partisan gerrymandering as a justification for squeezing out majority-Black districts.
  • Justice Alito's opinion in *Callais* suggests that admitting to partisan gerrymandering can serve as a defense against claims of racial discrimination under Section 2 of the Voting Rights Act.
  • The Court's embrace of "color-blindness" is criticized for ignoring the historical link between race and partisanship and the continued existence of racial discrimination.
  • The fallout from *Callais* may strengthen the relationship between race and partisanship, potentially diminishing the electoral relevance of Black voters in some Southern states.