sports

February 3, 2026

Butler did it: 11 years on, was the NFL’s most criticized call actually the right decision?

The last time the Seahawks and Patriots met in a Super Bowl, a dramatic interception by an undrafted rookie changed the history of both franchises

Butler did it: 11 years on, was the NFL’s most criticized call actually the right decision?

TL;DR

  • Malcolm Butler's interception in Super Bowl XLIX is a pivotal moment that changed the history of the Seahawks and Patriots.
  • The play occurred in the final minute with Seattle on the Patriots' one-yard line, leading to a dramatic upset victory for New England.
  • Butler, an undrafted rookie at the time, thwarted a pass intended for Ricardo Lockette, securing the Patriots' fourth Super Bowl win.
  • The interception is considered one of the most dramatic plays in Super Bowl history, with lasting implications for both teams.
  • The article suggests the play contributed to internal divisions within the Seahawks and a decline in their success, while the Patriots continued to win.
  • Butler reflects on the play's life-changing impact and his current activities, including coaching and community work.
  • Despite the Seahawks' regret over not running the ball, Butler defends the Patriots' defensive readiness for the pass play.

Continue reading the original article

Made withNostr