Supreme Court backs pregnancy center in donor subpoena fight

The Supreme Court handed a crisis pregnancy center a significant win on Wednesday in the anti-abortion center’s bid to quash New Jersey‘s subpoena demanding it hand over its donor lists, after the center successfully argued it was unlawfully targeted.

Supreme Court backs pregnancy center in donor subpoena fight

TL;DR

  • The Supreme Court granted a win to a crisis pregnancy center, First Choice Women’s Resource Centers, regarding a New Jersey subpoena for its donor lists.
  • The center argued the subpoena unlawfully targeted it and chilled its First Amendment free speech rights.
  • The Supreme Court found the center had established a "present injury" to its First Amendment rights, permitting the case to proceed in federal court.
  • The subpoena, issued by then-New Jersey Attorney General Matthew Platkin, demanded donor names as part of an investigation into alleged misleading of donors.
  • Justices appeared skeptical of New Jersey's claims that the subpoena did not unlawfully chill the center's free speech rights.