Pope Leo Can’t Have It Both Ways

The two people in the world who should feel most obliged to be thoughtful and restrained in their public statements are the president of the United States and the pope. But neither of the current incumbents seems willing or able to rise above his immediate political impulses as is necessary to protect the institution he leads.

Pope Leo Can’t Have It Both Ways

TL;DR

  • President Trump and Pope Leo XIV are accused of "trolling" each other, engaging in public goading and baiting.
  • Trump's criticism of the Pope and a doctored image are seen as tasteless and an abuse of presidential stewardship.
  • Pope Leo's criticisms of U.S. foreign policy and war are deemed historically inaccurate pacifism and a misuse of doctrine.
  • The Pope's comments are suggested to be influenced by political advisors, turning the Vatican into a partisan tool.
  • Both leaders are criticized for failing to calibrate their actions against historical norms and intellectual honesty.