Identity Politics Is a Problem for Conservative Christians Too
Turn any article into a podcast. Upgrade now to start listening.

TL;DR
- Polarization in the U.S. was worsened by political divisions during the COVID-19 pandemic, with both the left and right cherry-picking science to serve political opponents.
- Identity politics, which emerged on the left in the mid-19th century, defines political work around the elaboration, expression, or affirmation of identity, often for marginalized groups.
- Progressive identity politics led to movements like MeToo and Black Lives Matter, prompting conservative activists, like Donald Trump, to develop their own forms of identity politics, defining whites, men, and Christians as oppressed groups.
- Christian identity politics has recently focused on Christians as an oppressed group, a shift from earlier activism centered on issues like abortion and sexuality.
- Dysfunctional tendencies of identity politics include dehumanizing opponents, seeking out internal 'heretics,' and suspending intellectual consistency and moral standards to achieve goals.
- Conservative Christians engaging in identity politics have exhibited tendencies to malign other Christians who do not support Trump or the Republican party, and used dehumanizing rhetoric against undocumented immigrants.
- The author argues that Christian identity politics is a better explanation for the recent political activism of conservative Christians than Christian nationalism, as it recognizes their actions are similar to other political groups.
- A dangerous consequence is the conflation of Christian faith with political fidelity, suggesting that being a good Christian requires being a Republican, thus cheapening the concept of salvation.
- While political engagement by conservative Christians is not inherently problematic, it should not be locked into an identity political framework that demonizes others and prevents compromise.
- Overcoming polarization requires intentional steps, and while conservative Christians are not the sole source of identity politics problems, their entry into it is a significant concern.
- A path toward a healthier society involves constructive conversations that seek solutions acceptable across different groups, prioritizing compromise and listening to others, moving away from the problems of identity politics.