French director of Nazi collaborator film rejects ‘historical gaslighting’ claims

Xavier Giannoli says criticism that Les Rayons et les Ombres invites sympathy for characters is ‘profoundly dishonest’

French director of Nazi collaborator film rejects ‘historical gaslighting’ claims

TL;DR

  • Director Xavier Giannoli and actor Jean Dujardin are responding to criticism that their film "Les Rayons et les Ombres" has whitewashed wartime atrocities.
  • The film recounts the story of Jean Luchaire, a pacifist who became a Nazi collaborator and was executed for treason.
  • Giannoli rejects accusations of "historical gaslighting," stating he worked with historians and that the criticism is "factually false" and politically motivated.
  • Critics, including historians, claim the film downplays the role of the French resistance and the fate of Parisian Jews, and encourages empathy with the collaborators.
  • The film, narrated from the perspective of Luchaire's daughter Corinne, who also collaborated, has drawn over 800,000 viewers in France.
  • Giannoli believes the current political climate, particularly the rise of the National Rally party, may have influenced the critical reactions.
  • Dujardin stated that dictators are not always monsters and that Luchaire was a "paradox."