Readers reply: Why are national anthems almost always orchestral?
The long-running series in which readers answer other readers’ questions on subjects ranging from trivial flights of fancy to profound scientific and philosophical concepts
TL;DR
- National anthems were typically written before recorded music and designed for performance by large ensembles of portable instruments, such as military bands.
- Most anthems pre-date the electronic era and were composed for traditional instruments, often with choral harmonization.
- The musical style and lyrical content of many anthems are questioned in a modern, internationalist, and secular context.
- Examples of modern anthems, like Niger's and Syria's, are noted for their cinematic qualities.
- The origins of anthems are diverse, including folk songs, court dances, religious hymns, drinking songs, and even film themes.
- Performances can vary, with Jimi Hendrix's rendition of 'The Star Spangled Banner' cited as an example of a non-traditional, impactful performance.
- Some readers suggest alternative tunes, like movie themes or TV show themes, as more fitting national anthems.
- The British anthem, 'God Save the King,' is criticized for its perceived dirge-like quality and unspecific lyrics.