Sanctions don’t result in regime change. Whether against Iran or Russia, western countries need shrewder tactics
Dissent cannot take hold in soil rendered barren by emigration and embargo. Political opposition needs academic and cultural exchange if it is to prosper

TL;DR
- Britain's economy is facing significant damage due to sanctions against Iran and Russia, collateral from US foreign policy.
- Sanctions against Russia and Iran have not achieved their intended goals of regime change or halting nuclear programs; in fact, Russia's economic growth has sometimes outpaced Britain's.
- The US imposes sanctions on numerous countries, yet many continue to be ruled by the same regimes.
- Sanctions have strengthened the Sino-Russian trade alliance and encouraged developing nations to embrace the Brics partnership over the G7.
- Historical studies indicate that sanctions are generally ineffective, with trade finding ways around them, and they do not impact countries immune to internal democracy.
- Sanctions are espoused by military thinkers and liberals as a tough-sounding alternative to force or pacifism, but they avoid demonstrating actual results and disproportionately harm the poor.
- A significant consequence of sanctions is the emigration of mercantile and professional classes from targeted nations, weakening potential forces for regime change.
- Both Iran and Russia have experienced significant emigration of educated citizens, which has hollowed out the educated class and diminished the potential for dissent and democratic reform.
- The author argues that for genuine regime change without military invasion, the West must use soft power, including political aid and academic and cultural exchange, not crude economic pressure.
- Sanctions are deemed illiberal as they encourage victim nations to tighten borders and repress opposition, hindering the development of alternative elites and internal change.