Supreme Court turns away another parental rights dispute on gender-identity policies in schools
Updated on: April 27, 2026 / 9:58 AM EDT / CBS News
TL;DR
- The Supreme Court declined to hear an appeal from a Florida couple regarding a school policy on student name and pronoun changes.
- The couple alleged their parental rights were violated because the school did not inform them about their daughter's request to use different pronouns and a new name.
- The Supreme Court's decision avoids ruling on the conflict between parental rights and student privacy concerning gender identity in schools.
- At least three justices have previously indicated interest in addressing whether schools violate parental rights by affirming a student's gender transition without parental knowledge.
- The case originated from a 2018 policy by the Leon County School Board in Florida, which aimed to balance student privacy, safety, and parental notification.
- The policy allowed schools to support a student's asserted gender identity privately, seeking student consent before notifying parents if it could endanger the student's well-being.
- In 2021, the parents sued the school board, but their case was dismissed by the trial court and upheld by a federal appeals court.
- The appeals court ruled that while the school infringed on the parents' rights, they failed to prove a violation of substantive due process rights.
- Several states have enacted laws similar to Florida's 'Parents' Bill of Rights,' emphasizing parental control over child upbringing and education.