Sir Humphrey moments: a brief history of bust-ups between ministers and mandarins

Olly Robbins gave MPs a classic civil servant’s performance – and there are lessons from the past about how ministers should respond

Sir Humphrey moments: a brief history of bust-ups between ministers and mandarins

TL;DR

  • The article uses the TV show 'Yes Minister' as a metaphor for the relationship between politicians and civil servants.
  • Olly Robbins' appearance before a select committee regarding Peter Mandelson's vetting is compared to past civil servant-politician disputes.
  • Examples of past clashes include Michael Howard and Derek Lewis, Stephen Byers and Martin Sixsmith, and Geoff Hoon and David Kelly.
  • Former civil servants and politicians note that civil servants often know "where the bodies are buried" and that the public dislikes scapegoating.
  • The article suggests that the intensification of the media cycle and the rise of special advisers have negatively impacted politicians' behavior and the constitutional system.
  • There is a perceived decline in faith in the civil service's core values of impartiality and integrity.