What the Birthright Case Is Really About

Do we want to be the America of John C. Calhoun or Frederick Douglass?

What the Birthright Case Is Really About

TL;DR

  • President Trump's challenge to birthright citizenship echoes 19th-century racist arguments against the Fourteenth Amendment.
  • The Fourteenth Amendment's language was deliberately broadened to include all persons born in the U.S., not just former slaves.
  • Trump's arguments and policies reflect a racial determinism and a desire to reverse Reconstruction-era equality.
  • Historical figures like John C. Calhoun and Stephen A. Douglas held views that the Constitution was intended only for white men.
  • The case before the Supreme Court raises fundamental questions about the nature of American citizenship and national identity.
  • The outcome depends not only on the Court's decision but also on the will of the people to uphold constitutional principles of equality.