Supreme Court Upholds Constitution in Colorado ‘Conversion Therapy’ Case

The Supreme Court’s 8-1 ruling this week in Chiles v. Salazar is about more than one Christian counselor in Colorado and the state’s ham-fisted attempt to silence her. It is a window into one of the defining tensions of our political moment: the collision between the intolerance of modern progressivism and the enduring discipline of those — whether originalist conservatives or old-school liberals — who still believe the Constitution means what it says.

Supreme Court Upholds Constitution in Colorado ‘Conversion Therapy’ Case

TL;DR

  • The Supreme Court ruled 8-1 against Colorado's ban on counseling for minors exploring gender identity.
  • The majority opinion, written by Justice Neil Gorsuch, found the law to be viewpoint discrimination, violating the First Amendment.
  • The ruling highlights a tension between modern progressive ideology and constitutional free speech principles.
  • Justices Kagan and Sotomayor concurred with the majority, citing classical free-speech principles.
  • Justice Ketanji Brown Jackson dissented alone, arguing the ruling could harm states' ability to regulate medical care.
  • The decision puts 23 states and the District of Columbia with similar bans on notice.