How to Fix DHS
The answer to the agency’s abuses is not reform; it is wholesale disassembly and restructuring.
TL;DR
- DHS faces issues with FEMA's capacity and perceived chaos within TSA.
- ICE and Border Patrol are described as "rogue agencies" accused of violence and disregarding the rule of law, with ICE violating court orders and implementing unconstitutional search policies.
- The original mission of DHS was to prevent foreign terrorist attacks after 9/11, consolidating various anti-terrorism functions.
- Over time, DHS incorporated components with less clear ties to its original mission, such as immigration status adjudication and interior immigration enforcement.
- The rise of domestic terrorism radicalized by foreign propaganda presented challenges, as DHS's focus on international aspects left it less equipped to handle internally originated threats.
- The "force multiplier effect" has been exploited, leading to Border Patrol agents operating in the urban interior, encountering citizens outside their primary enforcement authority.
- The proposed solution involves returning DHS to its original focus on foreign counterterrorism, disaggregating most of its components, and returning them to more appropriate federal departments.
- FEMA should become independent again, and immigration adjudication could return to the Department of Justice.
- Disestablishment of DHS should include reforms to prevent the creation of a federalized interior police force, with ICE being reined in and restructured.