What's behind the Trump-Meloni divorce?
President Donald Trump threatened last week to withdraw troops from Italy. The threat followed his public accusation that Prime Minister Giorgia Meloni “lacked courage” after she defended Pope Leo XIV against Trump’s attacks, and refused to allow U.S. warplanes to transit Italian airspace for strikes on Iran. These two leaders began 2025 as close allies. That now seems like a long time ago.

TL;DR
- President Trump threatened to withdraw troops from Italy after Prime Minister Meloni defended Pope Leo XIV and denied U.S. warplanes transit for strikes on Iran.
- Past tensions include Trump's tariffs on Italian goods, increased energy prices due to the war against Iran, and Trump's remarks about European allies' involvement in Afghanistan.
- A significant portion of Italian voters hold unfavorable views of Trump, impacting Meloni's domestic standing and her association with Washington.
- Underlying anti-American sentiment in Europe predates Trump, with polls showing a notable percentage of Italians viewing the U.S. as a threat.
- European leaders' catering to public skepticism rather than explaining security threats has led to constraints, as seen in Meloni's inability to permit overflight during operations against Iran.