unknown
April 30, 2026
You be the judge: my partner likes open sandwiches. I prefer two slices of bread. Who is right?
Carol thinks Scandinavian-style sandwiches are unwieldy and messy, while Lucas wants to get the most from his fillings. You decide who’s the bread winner Find out how to get a disagreement settled or become a juror
TL;DR
- Carol believes sandwiches should be practical, with fillings neatly contained between two slices of bread.
- Lucas prefers open-faced sandwiches, common in Scandinavia, arguing they allow for more filling and enjoyment.
- Carol finds Lucas's method messy, with ingredients spilling out, comparing it to his taco-making style.
- Lucas defends his use of a Norwegian cheese slicer and argues that bread shape and a desire for generous fillings contribute to any 'mess'.
- He believes his approach maximizes the enjoyment of ingredients and that there isn't a single correct way to make a sandwich.
- Guardian readers offer their opinions, with some agreeing with Carol's definition of a sandwich and others supporting Lucas's right to eat as he enjoys.