Something Is Happening to America’s Moral Code

A New York Times podcast hosted Hasan Piker and a New Yorker staff writer for a discussion of lawbreaking, which they both endorsed as resistance to tyranny.

Something Is Happening to America’s Moral Code

TL;DR

  • The article critiques a New York Times podcast where Hasan Piker and Jia Tolentino discussed and endorsed lawbreaking, such as shoplifting, as resistance to tyranny.
  • The author contrasts this with James C. Scott's idea of 'anarchist calisthenics' and traditional civil disobedience, emphasizing the importance of accepting consequences.
  • The piece questions the participants' endorsement of 'cool crimes' and their perceived hypocrisy, particularly given their criticisms of corporations and praise for authoritarian states.
  • It argues that their views lack depth and ignore historical leftist movements and the practical realities of crime and societal change.
  • The author suggests a lack of 'muscle' and willpower for collective action among those advocating for petty disobedience without genuine risk or commitment.