Birthplace Alone Does Not Confer Citizenship

Turn any article into a podcast. Upgrade now to start listening.

Birthplace Alone Does Not Confer Citizenship

TL;DR

  • The Supreme Court is hearing *Trump v. Barbara* concerning birthright citizenship for children born to parents in the U.S. temporarily or unlawfully.
  • The article argues that the 14th Amendment's citizenship clause requires being 'subject to the jurisdiction' of the U.S., meaning full and complete jurisdiction.
  • Historical context and legal interpretations suggest this condition excludes children of those without a permanent connection to the U.S.
  • Arguments against this interpretation, including reliance on English common law and concerns about demeaning children, are addressed and refuted.
  • Previous Supreme Court cases and statements by framers of the 14th Amendment are cited to support the interpretation that temporary presence does not confer automatic citizenship.