Americans Should Stop Using the Term Christian Nationalism

Religious beliefs have driven political change for centuries. The question today is which Christian values will prevail.

Americans Should Stop Using the Term Christian Nationalism

TL;DR

  • The book *Chosen Land* by Matthew Avery Sutton argues that the pursuit of a "Christian America" is a long-standing national obsession with diverse historical manifestations.
  • The contemporary discourse on Christian nationalism often overlooks historical progressive Christian movements, such as the New Deal social gospelers and Black Christians' engagement with faith and politics.
  • The article suggests that the term "Christian nationalist" has become a dismissive label, hindering a nuanced understanding of the diverse ways Christianity has influenced American politics throughout history.
  • Historically, Christian ideals and activists have been central to American development, contributing to both progress (e.g., civil rights, workers' rights) and harm (e.g., slavery, Indigenous displacement).
  • The author proposes that the focus of critique should be on the specific values promoted by Christian political movements, rather than the mere fact of their engagement in politics.
  • The term Christian nationalism lacks a stable historical referent and its dismissive use may hinder productive dialogue and understanding.
  • The future of American political and cultural life will likely be shaped by which vision of Christianity gains traction, rather than whether Christianity will influence the country.