California’s “Stop Nick Shirley Act” Would Penalize Journalism

The First Amendment was designed to prevent exactly this; a law that punishes speech before any court decides whether it was harmful.

California’s “Stop Nick Shirley Act” Would Penalize Journalism

TL;DR

  • California Assembly Bill 2624 (AB 2624), nicknamed the 'Stop Nick Shirley Act,' passed the Assembly Privacy and Consumer Protection Committee.
  • The bill would allow individuals affiliated with 'designated immigration support services' organizations to demand the removal of their online images and personal information.
  • Penalties for non-compliance include civil fines starting at $4,000, potentially tripling to $12,000, and criminal charges with fines of $10,000 for inciting harm.
  • Critics argue the bill is a form of prior restraint and censorship, lacking exemptions for journalists and potentially suppressing investigations into fraud and abuse.
  • Supporters claim the bill is a necessary safety measure against targeted harassment and doxxing of individuals working with immigrant communities.
  • The bill's definition of 'designated immigration support services' is broad, potentially covering many organizations.
  • The bill requires a written 'reasonable fear' standard to trigger protections, which is determined by the claimant, not a court.
  • Opponents, including investigative video creator Nick Shirley, believe the bill is designed to protect waste and fraud by silencing those who expose it.