politics

What Do Sex and Gender Even Mean Now?

The history of a semantic mess––and a way out of it

What Do Sex and Gender Even Mean Now?

TL;DR

  • The terms 'sex' and 'gender' have historically had distinct meanings: sex referring to biological attributes and gender to socially constructed roles.
  • The distinction began to blur with the introduction of concepts like 'gender role' and 'gender identity', influenced by researchers like John Money and Robert Stoller.
  • Feminist scholars in the 1970s used 'gender' to differentiate social constructs from biological 'sex', but this distinction became difficult to maintain.
  • By the 2000s, 'gender' acquired a dual meaning: social norms and an internal sense of self or identity, further complicating its usage.
  • Current confusion in usage leads to problems in data collection (e.g., Australian census), scientific research (e.g., JAMA Ophthalmology study), and public debate (e.g., sports eligibility).
  • A proposed solution is to consistently use 'sex' for biological matters and 'gender' for socially constructed aspects, including gender identity and expression, to improve clarity and mutual understanding.