tech
We are preparing to transform the moon and Mars. The public must have a say in this future
The Artemis missions are paving the way to civilizational decisions. It’s time to ask not just what we can do – but whether we should do it
TL;DR
- Artemis missions are significant technical achievements, with Artemis II sending astronauts farther than ever before.
- The missions are seen as rehearsals for returning humans to the lunar surface and establishing a sustained presence, potentially as a staging ground for Mars.
- Decisions about the purpose and use of the moon are being made with little public deliberation by governments, international partners, and private companies.
- What is proposed is transformation (industry, resource extraction, military infrastructure) rather than simple exploration.
- While scientific reasons for lunar return are compelling (e.g., a radio telescope on the far side), they do not require a permanent industrial presence.
- The idea of Mars as a backup for Earth is questioned, suggesting focus should be on saving Earth.
- A serious and inclusive public conversation is needed before permanent lunar infrastructure is established.
- Questions are raised about our moral obligations to the moon itself, beyond its potential as a resource.