economy

'Buy the haystack': how tracker funds beat searching for shares

Designed to mirror the stock market, they are an easy and cheap way to save. Here’s how to start investing in them

'Buy the haystack': how tracker funds beat searching for shares

TL;DR

  • Tracker funds passively follow financial market indices, offering diversification by investing in a broad range of assets.
  • They typically have lower charges than actively managed funds because they do not require a dedicated management team.
  • Historically, tracker funds have frequently outperformed actively managed funds, with fewer than 24% of active managers beating trackers over the past decade.
  • Diversification is a key benefit, effectively spreading risk across all companies within an index, as famously described by Jack Bogle's 'buy the haystack' analogy.
  • Trackers can be structured as Exchange-Traded Funds (ETFs) or traditional Open-Ended Investment Companies (Oeics), with ETFs offering intraday trading flexibility.
  • Investment in trackers is recommended for the long term, ideally at least five years, to allow markets to recover from volatility and for returns to compound.
  • Investors should carefully check charges, as ETFs are not always cheaper than equivalent mutual funds.
  • Trackers can follow major indices like the FTSE 100 or S&P 500, or more niche indices related to specific sectors like wind energy or cloud computing.
  • Investors should verify what a tracker fund includes to ensure alignment with personal values, as not all trackers have ethical or sustainable criteria.
  • Investment can be made directly through fund providers, online platforms, or app-based banks, ideally within a tax-efficient ISA.
  • The barrier to entry for ETFs is low, allowing investment to start with a single share.
  • The inclusion of specific companies, like SpaceX after its IPO, in tracker funds depends on the index provider's rules and the fund's tracked index.
  • Long-term performance examples show significant growth for investments in tracker funds over five and ten-year periods.